iPhone Exchange Support

Wednesday, June 20th, 2007

The big blog news this week is Exchange email support on the iPhone. Financial analysts say the iPhone is doomed without it, Apple bloggers say you can enable IMAP on your Exchange server, and so on and so on.

There’s a few points I think people are missing though. First, email is only half the issue when you’re talking about Exchange. What makes Exchange impressive in the business world isn’t the fact that it gives you email, it’s how it integrates with calendars, your address book, public folders, and everything else in Outlook. It all tends to revolve around email, but when you’re talking about Exchange there’s simply a lot more to it then that.

Second, yes, you can enable IMAP on Exchange to give your iPhone users access to their email from outside the office. In my opinion though, that’s a terrible way to do it. Not just because it means extra configuration, documentation, changing firewall settings (and all the few select users at your company who might buy an iPhone), but because there’s a much easier and better way to handle this. Simply have the user create a free, web based email account and forward their Exchange email to it in addition to delivering it to their local mailbox. It take literally under a minute to do, and you can take advantage of push email on the iPhone if you use a free Yahoo! account. You could also just forward email to your user’s regular home email, but then you have to worry about them sorting the messages on their home email client, and you lose the push email features. I’ve been doing something similar with my email accounts for the past few months, and it works great; either from your cell phone, at home, or any other PC you may need to use.

In the end though, I don’t think it matters one way or another. Out of all of the users I work with that own an email capable phone, not one has ever expressed interest in using it with their office email account.

There are 11 comments in this article:

  1. 20/06/2007Charles said:

    Seriously? Almost everyone I know who has an email-capable phone uses it with their office email account.

  2. 23/06/2007Angelique said:

    I agree with Charles. I know I personally was ready to buy the iPhone as soon as it is released but once I found out it won’t synch with Exchange, I abandoned my plans….I have to have access to my email, calendar and contacts from work or it just isn’t worth it. Your workaround for the email is okay but then the user has to go back and delete everything from their mailbox that they processed through their phone – most corporate users won’t want the extra headache.

  3. 24/06/2007Markus said:

    I think the iPhone looks really cool, but without serious Exchange support, it is a non-starter for me. And the whole concept of forwarding email to another account is a dead end to IMO. One of the great features of a phone that integrates well with Exchange (like a Windows Mobile Phone) is that it truly integrates. When I read an email, it is flagged as read in Exchange and I don’t have to deal with it again. When I move an email to a different folder on my phone, it is moved in exchange. When I accept a meeting request on the phone, it goes on my Exchange calendar. I can even read my RSS Feed on my phone, and so forth.

    Forwarding an email, or usng POP, doesn’t do any of that. It would mean that I have to look at every email twice. I can already hardly handle the amount of email I get today. Doubling that workload is not my idea of a connected world…

  4. 18/07/2007Sean said:

    Also, the idea of mail forwarding is a non-starter for most since you can’t reply using the work account. It would be better to use Exchange Webmail than that. At least your mail gets marked read and you can reply.

  5. 29/07/2007Brad said:

    Ditto, Charles. It matters a lot. There are a lot of executives that would jump ship from the Blackberry if iPhone Exchange support were robust. With cheaper future iPhones, it could be entire companies doing the same. Apple simply MUST have a great team working on this. They couldn’t be THAT out of touch with corporations to not understand the importance.

  6. 29/11/2007TZ said:

    “can’t reply using the work account”…well you can set gmail to “reply as” or “reply from” and just enter your corporate mail account. Looks and acts like it…it will reply through your corp account…no?

  7. 7/01/2008chrispcritters said:

    Has anyone actually gotten exchange webmail to work with an iPhone?

  8. 16/01/2008Yesac said:

    The only reason to not sync the iPhone with a corporate account is the fact that you cannot remotely wipe it. If one gets stolen, misplaced etc… Well, I think you get the point. It’s not just protection for the enterprise, but protection for the user. If apple gets this, I think the iPhone has some real potential. The interface is killer, and it really has the only mobile browser that looks decent to use.

  9. 14/02/2008v4l said:

    Why it may be easy to forward mail from your corporate account to a free webmail account, it is not a good corporate security practice. One of the main reasons that enterprises like Exchange is the centralized account and information management which allows the enterprise to control the information it owns. Another reason that Windows Mobile and Blackberry are so popular within corporations is the ability for device administrators to wipe the devices remotely in case they are lost/stolen.

    The same point you made about Exchange can be made about devices and corporations, it is not just about e-mail there is a lot more.

  10. 17/04/2008Mike said:

    To echo what v41 said, forwarding corporate mail to a free webmail account is poor practice, and may be against your company’s security policies, as the webmail provider often has rights pertaining to the hosted content.

    From Google’s Terms of Service: “By submitting, posting or displaying the content you give Google a perpetual, irrevocable, worldwide, royalty-free, and non-exclusive licence to reproduce, adapt, modify, translate, publish, publicly perform, publicly display and distribute any Content which you submit, post or display on or through, the Services. ”

    Not necessarily a good thing in the corporate world.

  11. 18/04/2008chris said:

    all is good with your solution except most companies do not allow you to forward corporate email. Goes against most corporate email security policies. How bout we develope a secure VPN based solution for the iPhone or just allow a outlook web access client to run on the iPhone. Problem solved.

    Chris
    IBM ESMT